Annoyed by use of 'magic science' again
Apr. 23rd, 2025 07:44 amJust paid some attention to the plot, such as it is, of 'The Last of Us' - and I'm annoyed. The game - & apparently the series adapted from it - use the 'magic science' approach to immune response. A fungus infects victims, colonizes them & is an excuse for predatory zombies. [Sure, why not.]
But the problem is that when someone 'infected' with the fungus doesn't convert to fungal predator, the kid is called 'immune' - and is sought to provide BRAIN MATTER to search for a cure.
So - science magic. Wave the words around & provide Joel [the MC] with an ethical choice of letting the kid be murdered, or kill all the ones who want to murder the kid. And it is MURDER, since evidence is there that this 'scientific' approach has been used before to unknown numbers of OTHERS exhibiting fungal resistance and failed to produce a 'vaccine' every time.
What SHOULD they have done? NOT murder another victim, that's for damn sure. So - false choice for Joel. 100% save the kid/kill the threats.
Magic science COULD have done useful things. Like - keep the kid healthy & do intensive egg harvesting / embryo implantation in hopes that the kid's offspring - along with sprogs of OTHER, NON-MURDERED resistant folk - show the same resistance to the fungus.
OR be terrible & imprison the kid - along with other resistants after the failure of prior vaccine attempts. The logical inference of why vaccines showed promise & then failed is that it takes living blood / white cells / 'X factor' or some other 'life goo' to keep the fungus at bay. So imprison the resistants - keep them very healthy - and do transfusions from them to those in power.
Heck - even try to make an actual vaccine or effective fungicide without using lethal amounts of brain matter. Use non-lethal methods to harvest blood, bone marrow, bile, tiny amounts of cerebral fluid from LIVING resistants & keep trying other methods until they find something that works.
But the cycle of capturing and killing resistant individuals eliminates the chance for humans to breed for resistance or immunity - and this annoyed the holy living heck out of me. Because you can TELL that the prepared operating theater & 'doctor'-shill was using the lure of the 'magic cure'/vaccine to gain protection - and they had done this before and failed every time. It was the 'medicine is magic' promise that motivated everyone NOT a doctor to willingly die, enabling the continued lie.
But the problem is that when someone 'infected' with the fungus doesn't convert to fungal predator, the kid is called 'immune' - and is sought to provide BRAIN MATTER to search for a cure.
So - science magic. Wave the words around & provide Joel [the MC] with an ethical choice of letting the kid be murdered, or kill all the ones who want to murder the kid. And it is MURDER, since evidence is there that this 'scientific' approach has been used before to unknown numbers of OTHERS exhibiting fungal resistance and failed to produce a 'vaccine' every time.
What SHOULD they have done? NOT murder another victim, that's for damn sure. So - false choice for Joel. 100% save the kid/kill the threats.
Magic science COULD have done useful things. Like - keep the kid healthy & do intensive egg harvesting / embryo implantation in hopes that the kid's offspring - along with sprogs of OTHER, NON-MURDERED resistant folk - show the same resistance to the fungus.
OR be terrible & imprison the kid - along with other resistants after the failure of prior vaccine attempts. The logical inference of why vaccines showed promise & then failed is that it takes living blood / white cells / 'X factor' or some other 'life goo' to keep the fungus at bay. So imprison the resistants - keep them very healthy - and do transfusions from them to those in power.
Heck - even try to make an actual vaccine or effective fungicide without using lethal amounts of brain matter. Use non-lethal methods to harvest blood, bone marrow, bile, tiny amounts of cerebral fluid from LIVING resistants & keep trying other methods until they find something that works.
But the cycle of capturing and killing resistant individuals eliminates the chance for humans to breed for resistance or immunity - and this annoyed the holy living heck out of me. Because you can TELL that the prepared operating theater & 'doctor'-shill was using the lure of the 'magic cure'/vaccine to gain protection - and they had done this before and failed every time. It was the 'medicine is magic' promise that motivated everyone NOT a doctor to willingly die, enabling the continued lie.